Are Low Body Fat Levels Unhealthy?

Achieving the right body fat percentage is crucial for optimizing health and performance, but what exactly is the "right" level? With so much conflicting information available, it's easy to get confused about the ideal body fat percentage for your health. Can you be too lean, and if so, what are the consequences?

In this article, we will break down the complexities of body fat percentages, examining how different levels affect your health, hormone balance, and overall performance. We will also address common misconceptions and provide evidence-based guidelines to help you find your optimal body fat range. Whether your goal is to enhance athletic performance, improve metabolic health, or simply feel your best, this article will equip you with the knowledge to achieve a body fat percentage that supports your health and fitness goals.

Here’s what we will talk about:

· What Is True?

· What Is False?

· Best Practises

Is it true that having very low body fat levels is unhealthy? It might sound surprising, but it's a topic worth exploring. Every time a picture of someone with ultra-low body fat surfaces online, you’ll hear comments like, "That can't be healthy." Very lean individuals, especially bodybuilders close to competition, often admit that their low body fat levels aren't the healthiest. But is this belief accurate? Can you be too lean to maintain optimal health? And more specifically, can being extremely lean harm your health? Let's delve into the facts to understand when low body fat might be beneficial or detrimental.

What Is True?

Certain biomarkers, such as testosterone and estrogen, as well as markers related to bone building and tendon recovery, can take a hit when body fat levels are extremely low. This is a definite downside. For women, very low body fat can lead to amenorrhea, the absence of menstruation, which disrupts normal estrogen production. This disruption can result in long-term bone loss and is generally not good for overall health, as estrogen is cardioprotective for both females and males.

While it might not be entirely accurate to say that being lean is inherently bad for your health, the process of getting there can be problematic. The rigorous dieting and training required to achieve very low body fat levels can negatively impact health. It's akin to taking a perilous journey to the top of a mountain; the destination might be safe, but the journey itself is fraught with risks. The fatigue, stress, muscle loss, and poor sleep quality often associated with the hypocaloric conditions of intense dieting are more to blame than the leanness itself.

Additionally, when observing professional bodybuilders, it's essential to note that many use performance-enhancing drugs, which further compromise their health. However, natural competitors, who achieve similar levels of leanness without drugs, also experience significant health challenges. This suggests that the issues stem more from the diet fatigue and stress of the preparation process rather than the low body fat levels themselves.

What Is False?

There are at least three reasons why the belief that being lean is unhealthy might not hold up.

First, numerous studies show that reducing body fat improves health in many ways. Lower body fat correlates with better insulin dynamics, reduced inflammation, lower heart rates, improved blood pressure, and many other health benefits. The literature consistently shows that being lean makes you healthier, and there's no definitive evidence that extremely low body fat percentages (such as below 5-6%) are inherently harmful. While this doesn't conclusively prove safety at those levels, it does suggest we should be cautious about claiming they're dangerous without solid evidence.

Second, while certain biomarkers like testosterone and estrogen may decline with very low body fat, others improve significantly. For instance, cholesterol levels improve markedly as body fat decreases. As you get leaner, your cholesterol, blood pressure, fasting glucose, and A1C levels all improve. These markers are excellent indicators of health and longevity, with low fasting glucose and A1C levels being particularly anti-diabetic and life-extending.

Third, many metrics of brain health improve with lower body fat and caloric deficits, which are beneficial for long-term brain health. Although a caloric deficit can't be sustained indefinitely without adverse effects, maintaining a lean physique appears to support better brain function and health.

Overall, while some biomarkers do worsen with extreme leanness, a larger number show significant improvements, suggesting that being lean is generally more beneficial than harmful.

In many cases, it's more accurate to say that being leaner is healthier than not being lean. There's no doubt that many people will disagree with this, often based on the assumption that low body fat is unhealthy. This belief usually stems from seeing extremely lean physiques, like striated glutes, and assuming they can't be healthy.

This cynicism often seems to stem from a reinforcement of normative values that lack a solid foundation. It's similar to how long hair was once viewed as satanic in the 1970s—an arbitrary association without real evidence. The same applies to the belief that very low body fat is unhealthy. Historically, people thought being more muscular than average was strange and unhealthy. For example, NFL offensive linemen in the 1960s weighed around 100 Kgs because it was believed that muscle would slow them down.

When something deviates from the norm, people often assume it's bad, even if it's better. This happens with leanness today—many assert it can't be healthy, possibly as a way to justify their own less lean condition. However, there's little evidence to support this assumption, and it often serves as a way to maintain the status quo rather than engage with the real health implications of being lean.

Best Practises

Where does all this information lead us? There are upsides and downsides to low body fat, and here's the key takeaway:

If you're a woman of reproductive age, it's crucial to maintain a balance. Achieve your fitness goals, compete, take those photos, but then increase your body fat back to a healthier level, ideally above 15%. Keeping your body fat at a level that maintains a normal menstrual cycle is vital for long-term health.

For men, monitoring your blood work is essential. If you reach a low body fat percentage, like 6%, and people say it's too lean, your blood work will give you the real answer. If your doctor says your health markers are excellent, you can maintain that leanness. Regular blood tests every 3-6 months will help ensure you're on the right track. Some markers may fluctuate, but as long as overall health is maintained, you're good to continue.

Remember, many gymnasts and endurance runners maintain 5-6% body fat for years and are among the healthiest people in the world. If your blood work looks great, there's no need to worry about staying lean.

However, it's important to differentiate between being lean, healthy, and building muscle. Optimal muscle growth for men typically occurs between 8-20% body fat. For competitive bodybuilders, staying between 8-15% is ideal. Dropping below 8% body fat can hinder muscle growth as your body focuses more on replacing lost fat than building muscle. If you're aiming to build muscle, it's best to maintain a body fat percentage of around 12%, where muscle growth is most efficient. You can always reduce body fat later.

In summary, if you're concerned about being too lean for health reasons, get your blood work done. If everything checks out, you’re likely in good shape.

If this were helpful, it would mean a lot if you subscribe to my Newsletter. I love researching and writing about the stuff and sharing everything I find in my Newsletter.

Source: Renaissance Periodization.